Emerging Market Tech Series: The International Patent Mess

The tech world and the patent system have long been at odds.  The fast changing nature of technological innovation is ill suited to the slow and bureaucratic Patent and Trademark Office.  Last year’s Leahy-Smith America Invents Act sought to address some of the issues.  The act represented the most sweeping changes to U.S. patent law since 1952.  Among its major changes were switching from a first-to-invent to a first-to-file system and overhauling the way the PTO collects its fees.

While the bill made important steps in the right direction, it was lacking in a few key areas that are critical to the tech industry.  First, it made no major changes with regard to patent lawsuit reform.  If you have been following the current mess between Apple and Samsung it should be clear just how badly those reforms are needed.  Second, it did not go far enough in delineating the special needs surrounding technology patents.  Patents are lengthy, often lasting for 20 years.  In the tech market 20 years is an eternity.  Considering that technology tends to build off earlier innovations and new iterations frequently have components of old ones, this approach is particularly ill suited to the fast moving internet age.  In fact, just last week, Google’s Public Policy Director, Pablo Chavez, suggested it might be time to ditch patents altogether when it comes to software.

Yet, as complicated and convoluted as the American patent system can seem, it doesn’t hold a candle to the mess that is international patents.  Patents are country specific and their legal protection stops at a nation’s borders.  A patent in the United States does nothing to protect a company’s ideas in China, India, or any other country in the world.  To get truly global protection on an idea it is necessary to file for patent protection in multiple countries.  This means considerable time and expense spent on legal fees and wrangling with foreign governments.  On Wednesday of this week, the Europe Chamber of Commerce called on China to overhaul its patent system.  It cited low standards leading to too many patents being issued in instances that don’t warrant one as well as unclear standards surrounding national security reviews.  The group issued a 210 page report with 52 suggested changes.  If you need further evidence of China’s patent mess just ask the plethora of companies who have shuttered operations in China after serious intellectual property theft.  Multiply this problem by 194 and you start to get a picture of the serious challenges facing tech companies seeking patents abroad.

In today’s global supply chain components of a hardware device might be made in 5 different south Asian nations and sold in another 20 European countries.  Each country has its own deadlines, forms, and nuances.  The Patent Cooperation Treaty of 1970 streamlined the application process for international patents, but each nation still makes its own determinations and a truly international patent still does not exist.  As the internet age progresses and Moore’s Law seems as unabating as ever it might well be time to rethink the way patents are issued on an international level. 


2 thoughts on “Emerging Market Tech Series: The International Patent Mess

  1. Do not look at investing in the stock market as a hobby. It is something that has
    a lot of risk involved and it should be taken very seriously.
    If you do not have enough time, effort and patience to take it seriously, then you should not get yourself involved with it.

  2. Be aware that unscrupulous market advisers and stock scam artists can
    manufacture their own positive reviews! You should thoroughly investigate any
    online market resource before using it. Take random positive feedback
    with a healthy grain of salt. You will want to lend greater weight to reviews you find from
    truly trustworthy, unbiased sources.

    I really Love hot stock tips

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s